Skip to main content

IS IT A GOOD SIGN WHEN SOCIAL SECURITY SENDS YOU TO A DOCTOR FOR AN EXAM?

Once  Social Security receives your application for disability benefits they will obtain and review your medical records.  Sometimes they may feel that they don't have enough information to make a disability decision.  You can be sent to get an exam by a Social Security approved doctor.  This is called a consultative examination (CE).  This exam will be provided at no cost to you.

 A consultative exam (CE) may be a physical exam, a mental exam or a cognitive exam.  It will usually take place in your hometown or nearby. The doctor who examines you will be a neutral finder of fact--neither trying to help or hinder your case.  This doctor will report his/her findings to Social Security and the exam results will be used to further evaluate your claim.

It has been my experience that consultative exams are not usually conclusive:  they neither prove or disprove your disability.  And even if the exam is favorable, it doesn't mean that Social Security will approve your claim.  A consultative exam (CE) is a fact finding mission. 

You definitely want to attend any exam that Social Security schedules for you.  Here are some tips I give to my clients who are about to go for a consultative examination by a Social Security doctor:

1.  Arrive 15 minutes early.  Late arrival may mean that the doctor won't see you or that you won't have time for a thorough exam.  Be early.

2.  Have someone drive you to the exam if possible.  Ask that person to with you into the waiting room and wait there during the exam.

3.  Take all your prescription medications with you in their original containers.

4.  Don't smoke or be around someone who is smoking before the exam.  Doctors can smell smoke and often note it in their reports.  "Claimant denies smoking but he had a strong odor of cigarette smoke during my exam."  (This can be a credibility issue).

5.  Don't volunteer too much information to the doctor.  Answer the doctor's questions truthfully.  But avoid volunteering excessive information about yourself.  Avoid discussing such things as vacations, trips, gambling, drinking, sports or other activities unless you are asked about them.

6.  Don't try to "sell" the doctor on your disability.  Doctors don't get to decide who gets benefits and being an over eager patient can go against you.  Don't ask the doctor, for example:  "Do you think I am disabled," or "Do you think I will be approved?"  That's not the doctor's decision.   

7.  Don't exaggerate your symptoms or medical problems.  On the other hand, don't hold back or minimize your conditions or symptoms, either.  Be truthful and accurate.

Some Harmful Statements Claimants Have Made During Exams:

Claimants sometimes tell the doctor things that hurt their case.  Here are a few examples of things not to say: 

  • My hobbies are fishing, bowling, horseback riding and tennis.  (If you can't engage in those hobbies now, they are FORMER hobbies).  Mentioning them will make the doctor think you are still pretty active because you do those things, when really you haven't done any of things in months or years.
  • I stopped working in February to take care of my sick spouse, child, etc.  (This is not a disability; Social Security won't pay for it).
  • I quit working in September because my boss was awful and treated me unfairly and I just couldn't take it any more.  (Also not a disability).
  • I drink a 12-pack of beer every weekend.
  • I won $3,000 in Tunica last week so I've had a pretty good week.
  • My back has been worse since I helped my brother-in-law build a new barn (paint his house, repair his fence, put on a new roof, etc.).
  • I guess I could work a sit down job but it wouldn't pay anything and I couldn't live on what it paid.  (You just admitted you're not disabled).
  • I'm on my thirtieth week of unemployment benefits, so I hope I get my disability approved soon.
  • I got married last August, so I didn't need to work any more. 
  • I know that I'm more disabled than other people who are getting disability benefits...."

 Doctors are going to write this stuff down and send it to Social Security in their reports.  These statements may be taken out of context, exaggerated or misunderstood.

For example, the remark about helping your brother-in-law build a barn or put a new roof on his house will give the impression that you are able to stand, walk, climb, bend, stoop and perform other work-like activities associated with barn building, roofing, etc.  Therefore, you are almost certainly not disabled. The remark about winning $3,000 in Tunica says that you are able to take long drives, thus sit for long periods of time and freely engage in your hobby of gambling.  It just doesn't sound like you are disabled.

Answer the doctor's questions truthfully but don't volunteer too much, even in chit-chat or casual conversation before you think the exam as started.  The exam may really start when you walk through the front door.

________

The Forsythe Firm at Bridge Street.  Social Security disability lawyers.  (256) 799-0297.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

IF I CHANGE ATTORNEYS WILL IT DELAY MY DISABILITY CASE?

No.  Getting a new attorney will NOT delay your pending Social Security disability claim or appeal .  Your new attorney "inherits" the case and picks up where the other attorney left off.  There is no re-filing or starting over, so your case is not set back or delayed at all.  Social Security maintains an electronic folder stored in its system.  This folder contains every document ever submitted concerning your claim or appeal.  Your new lawyer may log into your electronic files and see, in real time, all the evidence and other documents in your file. While we do not recommend changing attorneys while your case is pending a decision, it is sometimes necessary.  You may need a new lawyer if your attorney dies, retires or  becomes disabled before your case is settled.  You may choose a new attorney without delaying or causing any set back to your case. If you are considering obtaining a lawyer to handle your Social Security disability case in...

URGENT MESSAGE FROM SOCIAL SECURITY'S TOP OFFICIAL - February 18, 2025

There is a lot of talk and speculation about Social Security in the new Trump Administration.  The acting commissioner of Social Security recently resigned and Lee Dudek has been appointed the new Acting Director. Today (2/18/2025) I received a message from the new Acting Commissioner Dudek.  Here is part of Director Dudek's message on Social Security for 2025:   Our continuing priority is paying beneficiaries the right amount at the right time, and providing other critical services people rely on from us. DOGE personnel CANNOT make changes to agency systems, benefit payments, or other information. They only have READ access. DOGE personnel do not have access to data related to a court ordered temporary restraining order, current or future. DOGE personnel must follow the law and if they violate the law they will be referred to the Department of Justice for possible prosecution.                      ...

SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY APPLICATION PROCESS

  Here is a brief overview of what takes place after you file your Social Security disability application : Application confirmation  – Social Security will mail you a copy of your application to sign. You will have an opportunity to review the application, correct any errors, and send it back to Social Security for processing. You must return the signed application. Social Security will not process your application until they receive your signed confirmation. And they don't send reminders about this. Function report  – Social Security will mail you a form called a function report . This form will ask questions about your personal care, meals, house and yard work, getting around, shopping, money, hobbies and interests, social activities,  and other abilities. This form will help Social Security determine what you can and cannot do on a daily basis. It must be filled out carefully and fully and returned. Work history report  – Social Security will ma...