Skip to main content

WHAT IS A "THEORY OF AWARD"?

If you listen to lawyers talk about Social Security disability you will hear the term "theory of award."  Judges often ask attorneys at the hearing, "What is your theory of award?"

A theory of award means:  What set of facts meets Social Security's rules to allow a payment of benefits?

It isn't sufficient to say, "The claimant can't work," or "the claimant is disabled."  The lawyer has to carefully examine Social Security's rules and explain which rule allows a payment or an award.

Here are some examples of a theory of award: 

 1.  The claimant's medical condition meets or equals Listing 12.05.

2.   Grid rule 202.06 will direct a finding of "disabled" based on the claimant's age, education, past work history and residual functional capacity.

3.  Based on the severe functional impairments, the claimant cannot perform past relevant work under 20 CFR §404.1520. 

4.  The claimant would be unable to perform any significant gainful activity which is available in the national economy using Medical-Vocational Guideline 201.04 as a guideline.  

5.  Pursuant to SSR 85-15, the claimant is unable to sustain any other employment available in significant numbers in the US economy.

Think of the Social Security disability process as a long, winding path. The path takes many turns and twists. The end of the path is the conclusion about how the regulations dictate a particular ruling.  Your lawyer always looks for a favorable decision at the end of your path--one which allows you to collect all the benefits you are entitled to get.

Only by explaining the legal reasoning can a lawyer expect to obtain a favorable ruling which pays his/her client.  That reasoning is the "legal theory of the case."  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

RED FLAGS IN SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY CASES

  RED FLAGS IN A SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY CASE A red flag is something that causes concern or raises a problem in a Social Security disability case.   In short, it’s something that may get the claim denied or cause a big problem. Here are some of the red flags that we see crop up: ·          Work after the alleged onset date (AOD).   Since the process takes so long, many claimants feel that they are forced to return to work for income.   Social Security often sees this as a sign that the claimant is not disabled. ·          Severe substance abuse.   Chronic and frequent abuse of drugs or alcohol can pose problems. ·           A skimpy work record.   A claimant who has worked very little or has jumped from job to job frequently may not have good credibility. ·          Quitting wo...
Post a Comment
Read more

WHAT YOU WILL BE ASKED AT A DISABILITY HEARING

Most Social Security disability claims will be denied twice:  First at the end of the Application process, and again after the "Reconsideration" process.  The third stop will be a hearing before a federal Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). It is here at the hearing level that most SSDI claims are paid.  So, what do you need to know about your Social Security disability hearing?     First, the judge will follow the rules established by the Social Security Administration.  His or her job is to determine whether you meet the particular laws and rules to receive disability payments.  So, it is a legal proceeding where you must prove certain things in order to get paid. Among the things you must prove:  Your insured status with Social Security:  You have worked recently enough and paid into the Social Security trust fund to gain the required "work credits" to support your claim.  You have a severe medical or mental impairment supported by adequa...
Post a Comment
Read more

HOW TO COMPLETE A FUNCTION REPORT OR ACTIVITIES OF DAILY LIVING FORM

After you apply for Social Security Disability (SSDI), you will be sent a FUNCTION REPORT to fill out and return.  This form asks a lot of very detailed questions about your daily activities:  driving, cooking, cleaning, dressing, visiting others, hobbies, etc. The Social Security Administration will use your answers to determine whether you can work or not.  You must show on this Function Report that you have limitations that do not permit you to work a full-time job.  You do this by showing your limitations in activities of daily living. Your goal in the Function Report is to show the struggles and challenges you have with everyday life.  It may not be sufficient to answer a question with "Yes" and fail to explain. For example:  "Can you drive?"  If you answer "Yes," Social Security will assume that your ability to drive is unlimited:  you can drive anytime, anywhere and as often or as far as you want.  That may not be true and would need t...
Post a Comment
Read more