Skip to main content

WHAT IS A "THEORY OF AWARD"?

If you listen to lawyers talk about Social Security disability you will hear the term "theory of award."  Judges often ask attorneys at the hearing, "What is your theory of award?"

A theory of award means:  What set of facts meets Social Security's rules to allow a payment of benefits?

It isn't sufficient to say, "The claimant can't work," or "the claimant is disabled."  The lawyer has to carefully examine Social Security's rules and explain which rule allows a payment or an award.

Here are some examples of a theory of award: 

 1.  The claimant's medical condition meets or equals Listing 12.05.

2.   Grid rule 202.06 will direct a finding of "disabled" based on the claimant's age, education, past work history and residual functional capacity.

3.  Based on the severe functional impairments, the claimant cannot perform past relevant work under 20 CFR §404.1520. 

4.  The claimant would be unable to perform any significant gainful activity which is available in the national economy using Medical-Vocational Guideline 201.04 as a guideline.  

5.  Pursuant to SSR 85-15, the claimant is unable to sustain any other employment available in significant numbers in the US economy.

Think of the Social Security disability process as a long, winding path. The path takes many turns and twists. The end of the path is the conclusion about how the regulations dictate a particular ruling.  Your lawyer always looks for a favorable decision at the end of your path--one which allows you to collect all the benefits you are entitled to get.

Only by explaining the legal reasoning can a lawyer expect to obtain a favorable ruling which pays his/her client.  That reasoning is the "legal theory of the case."  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MOST IMPORTANT FACTORS IN A SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY CASE

What are the top 3 most important factors in a Social Security disability case? 1.  Medical Evidence. 2.  Medical Evidence 3.  Medical Evidence 4-10     Medical Evidence Federal regulations set the eligibility requirements for Social Security disability (SSDI) benefits.  A claimant must meet these strict legal requirements More than anything else, the claimant's medical evidence will determine the outcome of the claim or appeal.  Without strong objective medical evidence Social Security cannot legally pay you a benefit. Objective Medical Evidence means the result of medical examinations, laboratory tests or imaging studies (X-rays, PT scans, MRI or CT scans). This type of evidence can only be obtained by going to your doctor. There's an old adage that says truthfully:  "The path to Social Security disability benefits runs straight through your doctor's office."  Being approved for an SSDI benefit requires objective medical proof. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

IS IT HARD TO GET SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY IN TENNESSEE?

  How hard is it to get Social Security disability (SSDI) in Tennessee? It can be very difficult.  In the beginning stages of the process, it seems like the agency is out to deny as many claims as possible.  Later--in the appeals process--it takes more technical and legal skill to move through the labyrinth of obstacles. What's the usual reason for an SSDI denial? If you look at all the denial letters, the most comm on reason given is:  You are not disabled according to our rules. The 2 main explanation for finding claimants not disabled are: 1.  You are able to perform some of your past relevant work. 2.  You can't perform any of your past work but you are able to do other work. Those are the two "catch all" reasons Social Security gives for nearly all of their denials.  Both of these reasons fall into the category of a medical denial .  The claimant's condition is not deemed severe enough to prevent all work. There are other reasons for d...
Post a Comment
Read more

CAN YOU WIN YOUR DISABILITY APPEAL WITHOUT A LAWYER?

The Social Security Administration does not require you to have a lawyer to file an appeal or to appear at a hearing.  However, most people heading for a disability hearing will hire a lawyer or advocate to help them.   Studies have shown that you are about twice as likely to win with a lawyer.  A recent study found that claimants with no lawyer win about 30 percent of the time while claimants with a lawyer or advocate win 60 percent of the time.   " He just cooked his own goose." These statistics cover only one aspect of a disability appear--your odds of winning. The other important aspects are time and convenience. If you prepare and adjudicate your own disability appeal, expect to spend 12 to 24 months working on the case.  You will be collecting, reading and submitting hundreds or thousands of pages of medical records.  These records are complex and often difficult to understand.  And you must know how each medical record helps (or hurts) your dis...
Post a Comment
Read more