Skip to main content

FLORENCE ALABAMA DISABILITY JUDGES

Disability hearings for claimants in Limestone, Madison, Morgan, Lauderdale, Lawrence and Colbert counties are held by judges in the Florence, AL hearing office.

The judges in the Florence office have a below average approval rate.  The national average award rate at the hearing level is 54 percent.  The Florence award rate (all judges) is 45 percent.  That may not seem like a big difference but it is.  

While I think most of the Social Security judges in Florence are fair, we have to wonder whether the 2 or 3 lowest paying judges are biased.  The lowest paying judge awards benefits to only 16 percent of her cases That is one of the lowest award rates in the nation. That's 16 out of 100.  Clearly, her perspective on "disability" is very different from that of the average judge.  Does she only pay claimants that are age 55 and over?  Does she only pay claims that meet Listing level impairments?  Does she think that only 16 percent of claimants have legitimate disabilities that meet Social Security's requirements?  I'm not sure but it takes a very different way of thinking to produce a 16 percent award rate.

The second lowest paying judge in Florence pays only 30 percent.  Far below the 54 percent average.  

Some of the judges in Florence genuinely try to get it right.  Yes, some judges are tougher than others--but most of them do try to be fair and follow the law.  They don't get every decision right because they are human. 

 But many have very bad experiences in Florence because it still is Social Security, run by the government, which is a complete and utter mess.  If you draw a judge with below 40% approval rate then you will need a very good case to win. That usually means that if you’re under 50 you must have a very debilitating condition-- or being 50 or over with a physical condition that prevents the ability to stand and walk--or even to sit for 6 hours a day. If you have sedentary work history within the past 5 years, it is virtually impossible.

But the wisest old adage in the world applies:  "It is what it is."  We work within the system we have.  We prepare the best case we can and present it as forcefully as possible.  But the one thing over which we have no control is:  which judge will you get? 

 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MUST YOU MEET A LISTING FOR SOCIAL SECURITY DISABILITY?

You hear talk of getting SSDI benefits by "meeting a Listing."  What are the Listings? The Blue Book listings are found in the regulations at 20 CFR 404, Subpart P, Appendix I. The Listings are divided into 12 body systems.  Each severe impairment is listed under its respective body system.  For example, Congestive Heart Failure is listed under Section 4.00 - Cardiovascular System. When you go there, there is a list of severe symptoms, and they are severe.   If you exactly meet or equal the list of very extreme symptoms you will be automatically approved for disability. Here's the problem:  Meeting one of the listings is about as likely as winning the Super Lotto.  It is very, very unlikely that you will do so. Thus, 99 percent of claimants do not and cannot get approved by meeting a listing.  The listings are only for catastrophic, extreme impairments that most claimants simply do not have--or do not have at the severity level demanded by the listings...
Post a Comment
Read more

A DISABILITY DENIAL IS NOT THE END OF YOUR CASE

By Charles W. Forsythe The Forsythe Firm Social Security denies a lot of applications.  It's expected.  But it's not the end. The good news is:  You can probably win your case on appeal and get paid benefits.  It just takes a bit longer. About 8 out of 10 new disability claims will be routinely denied.  So, it's rather unusual to be approved just by filing an application. An appeal sounds like a last resort or tricky legal maneuver.  It's really quite common--almost  normal--in a Social Security disability case. 8 out 10 claims will be appealed at least once, often twice, before they are paid. The process that pays Social Security disability is not the application, it's the appeal process. Many claimants who don't understand the importance of appeals give up after the first denial.  A serious mistake.  You odds get better in appeals. TIME LIMIT ON APPEALS .  All unfavorable Social Security decisions must be appealed within 60 days ....
Post a Comment
Read more

CAN A LAWYER / ADVOCATE HELP YOU IN DISABILITY HEARINGS?

 HOW A LAWYER INCREASES YOU ODDS     There are many things a trained disability advocate or lawyer can do for you in a disability claim.  The biggest reason to have a lawyer or advocate is that you are 3 times as likely to be approved when using one. As with all levels of applying for SSI and SSDI , it is not required that you have attorney representation. However, the hearing before an Administrative Law Judge is your BEST chance of being approved for Social Security benefits. During this stage your chances of being approved are highly improved by having an attorney that is skilled with disability law . Only an experienced lawyer or advocate will understand the difficult and confusing concepts discussed at the hearing.  If you don't have a lawyer you will probably understand very little of what goes on at your hearing. Before your hearing your attorney can prepare you for the questions you will be asked at the hearing. A vocational expert will be a...
Post a Comment
Read more